716-630-7091
If you've ever met newly engaged women; then you'll more than agree when we say that there's one question that everybody asks them..."How did he propose?". Getting engaged is a truly magical event and we love to hear how are customers popped the question. We invite you to read the world's most romantic proposals and maybe you'll find the inspiration in one of them to create some magic in your life.
My fiance always told me that she wanted to experience Christmas in New York City. So when I decided to get engaged I thought that it would be a prefect time to surpise her with a trip to NYC and a proposal. I had a hard time deciding where to pop the question as there are so many romantic spots in NYC. Eventually, I decided on Rockefeller Center while ice skating. When I we got there I paid s...
Date Submitted: 02/22/2008
My boyfriend and I always play scrabble together. One Saturday night while playing one of our competitive games, he seemed very nervous and anxious. Half way through the game he started placing the letters on the scrabble board that eventually spelled out "Marry Me". He then got down on one knee and asked me to marry him. I thought he was kidding! I couldn't stop crying and after I got myself...
Date Submitted: 02/22/2008
My fiance and I went on our first vacation to Disney World together. In January he decided to take me to Universal Studios. While we were there The Magic Kingdom was hosting a Pirate and Princess Party, so he took me to that. While we were there he bought a Pirates of the Carribean hat (like Johnny Depp's hair and hat) and bought me a blinking tiara. During the fireworks he told me I was one in a ...
Date Submitted: 12/02/2008
This being my second marriage, I decided that I wanted my children involved in making my new wife feel a part of the family. We went out and bought plain white tee shirts and a bunch of colorful markers. I invited twelve good friends to the beach house. Prior to my girlfriends arrival. We all wrote two Capital letters on our shirt. When she arrived we told her that we had to select a College ...
Date Submitted: 07/01/2009
My fiancée, Sheri and I just got engaged on May 29, 2010 and we’ve had so much fun sharing our story with friends, family and everyone else that wants to hear about it! Back in may, I noticed a customer of ours was tweeting about some contests regarding the Indy 500 and it got me thinking about ways I could propose to her. She is a huge race fan, loves cars and we’ve gone to the Indy 500...
Date Submitted: 06/15/2010
when me and my fiance first met it was love at first sight when he came to my house he was being a wiseguy like every guy is when he got the ring he got a bear with it and i knew that he had the ring so0 when i came down stairs that's when he got down on one knee and said will you marry me and i was crying because i was happy but i said yes because he's the best guy that I have been with i am so m...
Date Submitted: 02/16/2011
3 years ago today, my (now) fiance and I began dating. We met at Club Infinity in Williamsville, NY where I would spend every Thursday line dancing with friends. My fiance, Ian, had shown up one night and given we had went to school together, lived 9 houses away from each other and graduated together, we didn't know one another; probably never had never even spoken a word. As the night progressed...
Date Submitted: 11/04/2010
What a day. The day started out full of excitement. Not because I knew I was about to propose to my then, girlfriend and that if she said yes, we'd begin planning the rest of our lives together. What was more exciting was that I was in a basketball tournament. Im a professional basketball player so you know. On top of that it was my birthday! So I was just on cloud nine. My original plan wa...
Date Submitted: 04/22/2011
My fiance always wanted to go to NYC and never had the chance to travel there. So I thought that it would be great to surprise her with a trip to New York during the Christmas season. Its always so beautiful there in the winter and I wanted to propose to her on the ice rink at Rockefeller Center. When we got to the ice rink I paid one of the photographers that work the ice to be ready when I pr...
Date Submitted: 05/01/2008
Matt took me out to dinner at the Chop House for our 9th Anniversary of dating. While we were eating desert, he gave me a plastic case and said that it was an anniversary gift. The box was plastic and blue and had writing on it with a diamond in it. (it was the case for the diamond that he had purchased, the ring was not made yet) I did not know what it was and asked "what is this?" and then he ...
Date Submitted: 05/16/2008
My fiance and I love to go boating. We had recently purchased a new boat and decided to go out all weekend and celebrate our new purchase. We had also put money down on a diamond that I had picked out, but still owed on it before we could get it. On the day of his proposal, we went boating all day with friends and played some watersports. At the end of the day, we dropped our friends off at the ...
Date Submitted: 05/21/2008
It was our one year annaversary and he decided to cook for me so I went over to his house that night and when i got there he was all dressed up in a suit and on the kitchen table he had flowers and a balloon sitting in the middle. He told me to sit down he already had my plate fixed. He made smotherd chicken, corn on the cobb, and baked potatos. After we ate he told me to sit down he had a movie f...
Date Submitted: 06/24/2008
We went to Andrews Jewelers and he picked out my ring with me there, we then went home and he had made me wait til the following morning wondering when he was going to propose to me. We had our daughters birthday party that morning and I was busy putting things away and he camed around the corner and said I have to ask will you marry me and I was like you know I will and then he slid the ring on m...
Date Submitted: 07/05/2008
I was planning on surprising my fiance by getting engaged during a weekend trip to New York. My plan was to ask her at Rockefeller Center under the lighted Christmas tree. However, a heavy storm cancelled our flight, with the next available flight not until the following night. Extremely depressed at my plans falling through, we made an impromptu trip across the border to Toronto. Somehow, we ...
Date Submitted: 07/07/2008
our Story first starts off with the traditional ask your your future brides parents. He got up early to go ask my father for his blessing when he passed them driving on their way to church. My fiance tried flashing them down to get their attension. When they saw that he was behind them they both pulled over to the side of the road where Joe asked if he could talk to them both about me. They asked ...
Date Submitted: 10/27/2008
Well to make a long and funny story short, I attend a fairly small church (house of prayer). well the Pastor, who I suspect knew what was going on, called on my boyfriend (now finance) to sing a solo. At first I was thinking if its time to go home why is he about to sing a song? So Demare goes and starts singing and I honestly, after a hard days worship, was ready to go. So all the while he's sing...
Date Submitted: 11/09/2008
If you look up commitmentphob in the dictionary you will find my picture. Then I found not only my fiance but my best friend. I decided to propose and got the ring and have to say pulled this off with out her knowing anything was coming. I asked if she wanted to go out to dinner and took her to a restaurant where our friends work so it seemed like a normal Friday night. Well while we were at the r...
Date Submitted: 11/11/2008
We had talked about getting married for some time. We stopped into the local Andrews and just started looking at engagement rings. He had the salesperson to (who as it turns out, I work for the same company at his day job) hand me the ring. I put it on and Brad asked do I like it. I said well it's beautiful. Brad asked the price..and then said "we'll take it." I was floored because it was so sud...
Date Submitted: 11/13/2008
We are a young couple and since we met I knew that he was the one for me. He likes getting jewelery at Andrew's because that is his name, so it's really sweet. We didn't have a lot of money, so we had to put in layaway and make payments on it. Once it was paid off we finally went and got the ring. He put it away and we both tried not to think about it, but we couldn't wait! Outside of the mal...
Date Submitted: 12/02/2008
It Was Christmas eve morning and my fiancee and I were at home; I was finishing wrapping christmas gifts, because i had to work at 7am the next morning and he came to me and told me that he was going to go and finish up his christmas shopping. He was gone acouple of hours. When he left he had gone over to my parents house to ask for my hand in marriage. I had been upset about working christmas mo...
Date Submitted: 12/05/2008
My day started out busy and stressful due to Christmas around the corner. I arrived back home on a mission to take a nap before a planned visit to my parent's house. I ended up falling asleep on the couch in the family room. I was awakened by my then boyfriend to tell me to turn over and look at the view. When I did just that, I had instant tears. There on one knee with a box in his hand sat my ne...
Date Submitted: 12/20/2008
Robert and I have been dating for 5 years. We knew we always wanted to get married, but I still had 2 more years of grad school to finish before I even wanted to start thinking about planning a wedding. Earlier in the week, Robert mentioned that we should go to Niagara Falls at night to watch the fireworks that they do every Friday night. Since I had never been to Niagara Falls in the winter time,...
Date Submitted: 12/20/2008
Our actual engagement happened on August 10, 1999, but the date drop-down wouldn't let me go back that far. My now-husband ownes a classic '69 Mustang Coupe. We worked together at Meijer Inc and he was so shy that the only way I got him to talk to me was by complimenting his awesome car. I fell in love with the car and then I fell in love with him! We dated for a year and a half and then he as...
Date Submitted: 12/22/2008
My now fiance, Lee, and I, had been dating for a while and we were completely head over heels in love with each other. We talked about getting engaged but nothing too serious; at least I didn't take it seriously. I had no idea that in his head, he was secretly planning something special. The day it happened, he woke me up bright and early with a text message telling me how much he loved me. That, ...
Date Submitted: 12/27/2008
We decided to take a trip to the Finger Lakes to do some wine tasting. It was a warm, sunny day, and the first day of Autumn. We stopped by a little town called Skaneateles to have a picnic by the water. That is when he got down on one knee and asked me the big question. It was so romantic and sweet! It was such a suprise and yes I did cry.
Date Submitted: 12/30/2008
My boyfriend of 5 1/2 years, Matt, took me out on a romantic date on January 6, 2009, because I would be leaving soon to spend a semester of school in Washington D.C. While at The Melting Pot, a well-known fondue restaraunt, he got up to use the restroom. Really, he talked to our servers about getting a rose to give me my diamond ring on. They instead suggested that he give them the ring to put...
Date Submitted: 01/08/2009
For us, it was truly love at first sight. While our relationship seemed like a never-ending dream, our lives were shattered when my loving father was diagnosed with terminal kidney cancer. Knowing the special relationship between my dad and I, my fiance proposed to me on my dad's 63rd birthday. My fiance wanted to give me a special memory to look back on every year on my dad's birthday. My dad...
Date Submitted: 01/16/2009
My birthday fell on a Monday this year and being a high school teacher, there was no opportunity to celebrate that day having to wake up early the following morning. My birthday also falls during the Thanksgiving holiday break so my fiance decided that we would celebrate my birthday on that Friday, due to school being closed, by attending the Buffalo Museum of Science and then to a nice dinner. ...
Date Submitted: 01/27/2009
Okay so the correct date that I proposed to my wife was 7-11-04, and we were both going to Purdue at the time! My wife loves stars and Kit at Andrew's Jewelers helped my custom make the ring with stars engraved on them! I found a quiet little park and planned a great little picnic late at night so we could watch the stars and then I could pop the question! We had a great meal, then the bugs ca...
Date Submitted: 02/08/2009
My fiancee and I first met online around my birthday, I joke that she was my birthday present! I had never met anyone like her, she is funny, smart and had a great outlook on life. When we talked about the Holidays that meant the most to us, she said that she hated Valentine's Day. She had had a lot of relationships that didn't work out very well and was always alone or crying when Feb 14th cam ...
Date Submitted: 02/23/2009
My "new" fiance stayed with me on Saturday night. When I awoke on Sunday morning he was gone. I walked into my room to look for him, but what I found was a little heart shaped box. On the top of the box was the letter "I". Inside the box were rules, a piece of a puzzle, and instructions. The instructions told me where to go next. I went to the second location and found another box with instruction...
Date Submitted: 02/26/2009
Feb.27 was my 27th b-day. My family always come together to go out to dinner. My boyfriend made reservations at "Genji Japanese Steakhouse" for 8pm. I was surprised to see additional guests (about 35 people). Our table was running over, but I was elated at all the people who showed up for my birthday. After the cooks left our table, the waitresses and waiters came over to sing "happy birthday"...
Date Submitted: 03/04/2009
My day started off with Todd waking me up to go to breakfast. I knew he had something planned for me that afternoon, but he kept me in great suspense. At breakfast he finally let me in on the secret. It was a day of mani-pedi's with my favorite person, my sister. I thought what a thoughtful thing to do. Still, I was unsuspectful of what was to come. I knew we had dinner reservations later that nig...
Date Submitted: 03/19/2009
David and I had been vacationing in Florida for a week-visiting my grandparents. We spent every day on the local beaches went sight-seeing, just spent the week relaxing- Sunday afternoon David asked if I wanted to go back to a beach that we both loved going to because there was a walking trail with an amazing overlook point of the Gulf of Mexico-I agreed and off we went. We walked the trail, talki...
Date Submitted: 03/22/2009
September 9, 2008 was the day our lives changed. It was a little after 5pm on a Monday. Matt and I didn't have school that night so we planned on a date night. He was going to meet me at the apartment and then we were going to go out to dinner. As I was walked through the door, there on the floor in a trail, were long single stem roses. There were candles all over the apartment as well. My heart w...
Date Submitted: 05/16/2009
It was New Years and I went out with my girlfriend and her boyfriend to a hole in the wall bar. I was already feeling like a 3rd wheel and was at a bar I would never go to. We were at the club for about a half hour when I noticed my future fiance at the end of the bar. He walked up to our table asked me what I was drinking and walked away. My girlfriend looked at me and shrugged. While she was in ...
Date Submitted: 06/18/2009
We had been talking about getting married and ring shopping for a while. I very much wanted the actual engagement to be a surprise. Andrew waited until I was at work one day and then went to my parent’s house to ask my father's permission for my hand in marriage. My mother and sister came home in the middle, and he ended up asking (and receiving) my entire family's permission. So, the day a...
Date Submitted: 07/13/2009
For their third anniversary Jared took Nicole out to dinner to Mountain Jack's (yet another steakhouse:) ). He did this because Lonestar went out of business and he thought it was close to their original date spot. They had an AWESOME dinner. Nicole had left her stuff on campus and needed to go back to get it before going home. Jared decided to ask Nicole if she wanted to take a walk around ca...
Date Submitted: 07/21/2009
Rob and I had been best friends for 8 years, before we started a relationship with each other. After one year of dating and knew it was meant to be, Rob asked me to go to dinner with him to the Buffalo Launch Club. Instead on driving there, we took our boat to the restaurant. We were running a little early, so we decided to spend some time floating in the river and having a few cocktails!!! Wh...
Date Submitted: 08/23/2009
For my birthday in October, Fabyan gave me couples dance lessons (which I had been wanting to do for such a long time!). I did not know that the proposal would revolve around taking the lesson, as he did a lot of preplanning to make it such a surprise! On a random Thursday I got to work and a dozen red roses were sitting on my desk... but no card! I obviously thought the card had been lost or forg...
Date Submitted: 09/03/2009
Unknown to me, Chad had been preparing to pop the question months in advance while on our vacation in Florida. Chad was leaving early for vacation; he picked up the ring, quickly drove up to ask for my hand from my dad and hopped on a flight to Fort Meyers, Florida to spend two weeks with his parents. Later in the week I flew down to join him. The next morning everyone got up and got ready. Chad ...
Date Submitted: 09/23/2009
When it came down to propose I know that she would know what was going on because she is very noisey so i took her out to eat like a normal friday and proposed to her when we left the restaurant. not the best, but she said yes and that is all that matters!
Date Submitted: 09/28/2009
After six months of deliberation my fiancee decided to trust me and trust God to make the most important decion that we would ever make. About 8 hours prior I had already gone to Andrew's Jewelers to go ahead and buy the ring. Since I had the green light I took adavntage of it and talked to her dad the next day. After about a thirty minute conversation I had the approval from him, so everything...
Date Submitted: 10/05/2009
Last month my then boyfriend of 9 months (now fiance) proposed to me in front of the Bellagio fountains, at dusk, right after the song "This Kiss" played. He completely caught me by surprised when he took a knee & asked me to marry him. It was probably the fastest few minutes of my life but was VERY memorable (we were applauded by passers by) & I was shaking for nearly an hour afterward as we w...
Date Submitted: 10/19/2009
We woke up really early in the morining because Devin told me we were going to take aerial photos of his mother's house for her. Devin has his private pilots license and his mother has been nagging him to take aerial photos for her since he got it. I really thought it was going to be a boring day. So we drive to the airport and hop in the plane that we rented for the day. As we are coming up to...
Date Submitted: 10/22/2009
We were laying the bed just talking about things that needed to be done around the house, and in the middle of the conversation I asked her will you marry me, just out right, and she looked at me like I was joking and asked me and I said are you going to anwer and she said YES! We got married on October 3, 2009!! We got all of our rings from Andrew's..........
Date Submitted: 10/27/2009
It was one month after our anniversary. I had everything planned out. I was going to take Kristy to the Indianapolis Museum of Art to take some pictures and had planned on asking somebody to take our picture in front of the LOVE sculpture. I planned on asking her while somebody was taking the picture and capturing the exact moment. I had even gone down the day before to scout the location and l...
Date Submitted: 11/05/2009
Even though I know that Sweetest Day is nothing more than a commercial holiday, I was still a bit disappointed that my now fiance, Andrew, seemed less than enthused on that Saturday. Little did I know that he had made the important purchase of our lvies together earlier that morning. Exactly one week later, on Saturday, October 24th, Andrew and I were visitng friends in Cleveland, Ohio. Before st...
Date Submitted: 11/10/2009
My new fiance is a fire fighter and had his whole proposal planned out with his fire dept and my family. We all went out to dinner and my fiance said he had to go into work for a mandatory meeting and would meet us at the restaurant. Little did I know he was planning on popping the question at that restaurant that night! He pulled up with a HUGE sign on the fire truck that read "Will you marry ...
Date Submitted: 11/12/2009
I was out shopping by myself one afternoon when i happened to walk by Andrews where a very close friend works. I had been with my boyfriend for 6 years so I decided it was time to start looking for engagement rings. one of the associates pulled out the most amazing ring I had ever seen and it was over from there. My boyfriend wasn't even there and I had just put a downpayment on an engagement ring...
Date Submitted: 11/22/2009
Ryan woke me up at 8:30am this morning and told me to start getting ready to leave. I knew he was planning something, but he told me it was an activity to celebrate our 2 month anniversary. At 9:15am he told me to stand in the middle of my bedroom, close my eyes, and count to 60. After about 35 seconds I hear the rustling of paper at my feet and then heard him bolt down the stairs. At 59/60 second...
Date Submitted: 12/02/2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cU9kccmJb8 I was visiting my boyfriend for his graduation from the Air Force. I was just taking pictures and wanted a video of him and all his fellow wingmen. I had no knowledge of what i was recording. In the matter of seconds 43 just graduate airman surrounded us. His best friend did a march as you can see to Chayanne. He turns around shakes his hand and then tur...
Date Submitted: 12/07/2009
It happened to be my birthday when my boyfriend proposed to me. I knew something was up because he was acting so weird and he would barely even talk to me let alone look at me. I jumped in the shower real quick and when I was done I walked out to find some clothes to put on. To my surprise, my boyfriend for some reason decided this would the best time to propose. I stood there in shock in my under...
Date Submitted: 12/09/2009
My fiance at the time planned a trip downtown Indianapolis. He had arranged for my sister and her boyfriend to go downtown prior to our arriving and set everything up. My sister picked a bench right on the canal for all of the special things my fiancé had planned. There was a blanket, a balloon, a cake, roses, and a few other things. They got everything ready and then sent a text to my fian...
Date Submitted: 12/11/2009
My fiancee and I had watched 500 Days of Summer this year and loved it!. The movie was great but the dance sequence was, by far, our favorite part. I decided to use this to my advantage for my proposal to her. The day the movie had come out on DVD I told her we should go Christmas shopping at the outlet mall. When we got there, my friends and family were already set up with a stereo and ready to d...
Date Submitted: 01/10/2010
It was a beautiful day. The air was crisp and all the leaves were begining to change. My boyfriend and I decided that we would take a drive to Letchworth to see the leaves and the beautiful scenery. When we got there we stopped to almost every viewing sight to look at the gogeous views. Our last stop was at the train tressel that goes over a waterfall. I used to visit this place when I was a kid....
Date Submitted: 01/25/2010
My family and I are HUGE Ohio State fans and have been going to football games since I was a child. During football season in 1993 I had an accident climbing out of the "Buckeye Tree" on campus and was rushed to the hospital. Needless to say, I missed my first OSU football game!! Well 16 years later, my husband told me he wanted to go collect buckeyes from the "Buckeye Tree" for the upcoming foo...
Date Submitted: 01/27/2010
He had asked me several times over the past year. Every time he would ask, I would reply, "Maybe someday, but not today," because I just thought he was kidding around. After a while, I realized he was serious, but I kept responding the same way to see if he truely meant it or if he would give up. Christmas Eve 2009 my parents had stopped over for dinner. After dinner I was standing in the kitchen ...
Date Submitted: 01/28/2010
After work one day I went home and A friend of mine called and told me she was comming over. She was very insistant so i was a little supicious anyway. When she got the I recieved a text frommy fiance saying that we were going to play a game. My friend Jamie gave me a letter he had wrote to me explaining the rules of the game. Next she gave me my first clue. Each clue was a letter and each of thes...
Date Submitted: 02/02/2010
We got engaged on May 18th 2009. It was a day lie any other until a childhood friend called and said she was comming over to my house. She got there and told me to get dresses we had some places to go so I did and while I was gettin ready she handed me a letter. It was from my fiance, it was set of rules and a clue. The first clue lead me to his mom and then she gave me a clue that lead to my cous...
Date Submitted: 02/04/2010
After living in Buffalo for a few years, my boyfriend of 2 years knew that I wanted nothing more then a nice beach vacation for two. This summer we planned a trip to South Carolina to visit my parents, however I soon discovered that he had planned a weekend getaway for the two of us while we were there. I was not allowed to know where we were going, as the weekend planned was our 2 year anniversa...
Date Submitted: 07/26/2011
It was just an ordinary Wednesday, or at least I thought it was. I went about my day as I always did. After work I ran some errands, and even got a pedicure. I sent my 'soon-to-be' fiance a text message letting him know that I planned on running errands & getting a pedicure, because I rarely do anything but go to the gym after work! We later met at TGI Fridays for dinner. We had our normal un...
Date Submitted: 08/08/2011
Sunday after church, my girlfriend and I stopped at her house. While she headed downstairs to change a load of laundry, I hurried to a closet in her spare bedroom where I was hiding the ring and a leather bound journal. I placed the ring in my pocket and the journal on her coffee table. As she came upstairs, I told her I had a gift for her that we both could share. She was very surprised to see an...
Date Submitted: 08/09/2011
During high school football season, George goes with his friends to local high school football games, and this Friday (9/9/11) was no different.... or so I thought. So, I made plans with my bff to go to the Pork Festival in my hometown, Tipton, IN. George was supposed to come and join me later that night for the Mark Wills (country singer) concert after the football game. HOWEVER, right before Mar...
Date Submitted: 10/14/2011
We were engaged on New Year's Eve at The Statler City Ice Ball. When the ball fell and we rang in the new year I looked at Danielle and told her I had a question for her, I turned her around, got on one knee and asked her to marry me. It was great there was a photographer standing right next to us, we had no idea that he had video taped the whole thing. Check it out! http://vimeo.com/34435375
Date Submitted: 01/17/2012
Each year at the leukemia and lymphoma society fundraiser (diamond ball), a 1ct. diamond is given away to someone at random. Out of 650 people, my fiance was a final contestant. When asked what he would do if he won, he said he would propose to his girlfriend Charis. He then had to pick another bag and upon opening realized he was the winner! He started waiving me up front, got down on one kne...
Date Submitted: 02/28/2012
It was my fiance's birthday and after he had finished opening his birthday gifts from me he said, "There's still one more gift." He reached behind him and pulled out a ring box from behind pillows on the couch. He then asked me to marry him. I was in shock! I was not expecting it at all! :)
Date Submitted: 04/08/2012
It was my boyfriend's birthday and I had his gifts wrapped and under the window for a month or so. I was so excited to give him his presents that I begged him to open them up each night for a week or so leading up to his actual birthday. Days before he asked if I would take him out to dinner seeing how he is the one that usually drives and pays for a date night. I agreed and we decided to do gifts...
Date Submitted: 04/12/2012
There are no listings at this time.
Let him or her have all the fun by giving them an Andrews Gift Card.
Login